DeliveredCitationCourtJudgment 2013 09 20 Kongko Louis Makau & Department of Education Limpopo Province (JS879/2012) Johannesburg JS 879/2012 2013 09 17 UTATU SARWHU and others & Autopax Passenger Services (Soc) Ltd and another (J 1931 / 2013) Johannesburg J 1931/2013 2013 09 16 Kusokhanya Electrical Constructions CC & Themba Hlatswayo N.O. and 8 others (JR 875/2012) Johannesburg JR 875/2012 2013 09 13 Nedbank Limited & Commission for Conciliation Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR 3166/10) Johannesburg JR 3166/10 2013 09 12 Department of Health, Eastern Province v PHWSBC & others (P217/07 & P219/07) Port Elizabeth P 217/07 & P 219/07 2013 09 05 POPCRU & L G P Ledwaba N.O. and 3 others (JR 636/2012) Johannesburg JR 636/2012 2013 09 05 Manamela Nnana Ida & Department of Co-Operative Governance Human Settlements & Traditional Affairs Limpopo Province and another (J1886/2013) Johannesburg J 1886/2013 2013 08 30 Robert M Madzonga & Mobile Telephone Networks (Pty) Ltd (J1867/2013) Johannesburg J 1867/2013 2013 08 28 Moqhaka Local Municipality & The South African Local Government Bargaining Council (JR991/12) Johannesburg JR 991/12 2013 08 16 Mecs Africa (Pty) Ltd & Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR455/12) Johannesburg JR 455/12 2013 08 15 SACCAWU obo Makhubela & The Development Bank of South Africa (JS443/12) Johannesburg JS 443/12 2013 08 13 Unitrans Supply Chain Solution (Pty) Ltd & SATAWU and others (J1174/2013) Johannesburg J 1174/2013 2013 08 13 Intersite Property Management Services & Khululekile Mchuba and 2 others (JR1343/2011) Johannesburg JR 1343/2011 2013 08 13 Tiger Brands Field Services (Pty) Ltd & Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (JR 2650/2010) Johannesburg JR 2650/2010 2013 08 12 Jonsson Workwear (Pty) Ltd & Lawrence John Williamson and another (D426/2013) Durban D 426/2013 2013 08 06 Clencor (Pty) Ltd & Commisioner KG Mngezana N.O and 2 others (JR2779/06) Johannesburg JR 2779/06 2013 08 02 Jamafo and others & Pick ‘N Pay Retailers (Pty) Ltd and another (J1571/13) Johannesburg J 1571/13 2013 08 01 SAMWU obo MW Mokwalakwala & Polokwane Local Municipality and another (J1667/13) Johannesburg J 1667/13 2013 07 31 Rhoda Nompumelelo Yedwa & Nedbank Group Ltd. (JS 660/11) Johannesburg JS 660/11 2013 07 31 Armaments Corporation of South Africa (SOC) Ltd & CCMA and 3 others (J1673/13) Johannesburg J 1673/13 2013 07 3 0Abraham Legobate & Quest Flexible Staffing and 2 others (JR 221/12) Johannesburg JR 221/12 2013 07 30 Diphapang Jacob Mokoaledi & Minister of Health and 4 others (JR1904/12) Johannesburg JR 1904/12 2013 07 30 John Johannes Buys & Tokiso Dispute Settlement (Pty) Ltd and 2 others (JR815/12) Johannesburg JR 815/12 2013 07 30 SATAWU obo Ramalepe Matlatso & Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR381/12) Johannesburg JR 381/12 2013 07 30 Rudman, Janet & Maquassi Hills Local Municipality and 3 others (J1472/13) Johannesburg J 1472/13 2013 07 30 Kedibone Laucadia Sekwele & Minister of Comunications and another (J 1296/13) Johannesburg J 1296/13 2013 07 30 Ismail Nadia & B & B t/a Harvey World Travel Northcliff (JS 574/2010) Johannesburg JS 574/2010 2013 07 24 Chemical Energy, Paper, Printing and Allied Workers Union and another & Sambane Powder Coaters CC and another(J2661/09) Johannesburg J 2661/09 2013 07 24 T L Sejake & Naledi Local Municipality (J 148/112) Johannesburg J 148/112 2013 07 23 DEWDEV (Pty) Ltd T/A Bulkbag Manufacturers & Bargaining Council for the Canvas Good Industry, Witwatersrand & Pretoria (JR 169/09) Johannesburg JR 169/09 2013 07 18 Indico Risk Services CC & Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR2404/10) Johannesburg JR 2404/10 2013 07 18 Concor Holdings (Pty Limited & Daniel Mazibuko and 2 others (JR3147/2009) Johannesburg JR 3147/2009 2013 07 18 National Commissioner of the South African Police Service & JR Mokoena and 94 others (JR1583/2011) Johannesburg JR 1583/2011 2013 07 15 Autopax Passenger Services Soc Limited & South African Transport and Allied Workers Union and others (J 1207/13) Johannesburg J 1207/13 2013 07 15 National Union of Mineworkers & Lonmin Platinum comprising Eastern Platinum Ltd and Western Platinum Ltd and another (J 1118/2013) Johannesburg J 1118/2013 2013 07 05 Goldfinch Garments CC and another & The Sheriff of the Court – Newcastle the National Bargaining Council for the Clothing Manufacturing and another (D 393/11) Durban D 393/11 2013 07 21 National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa and another & KK Engineering (Pty) Ltd t/a KK Shelving (JS 293/12) Johannesburg JS 293/12 2013 06 21 Marizanne Pascal Van Alphen & Rheinmetall Denel Munition (Pty) Ltd (C418/2013) Cape Town C 418/2013 2013 06 21 NUM obo Mabote & CCMA and 2 others (C 1010/12) Cape Town C 1010/12 2013 06 20 Transport and Allied Workers Union of South Africa & Transnet (Pty) Limited and 2 others (J175/2011) Johannesburg J 175/2011 2013 06 18 Mayor: Greater Taung Local Municipality and 3 others & Mpho Simon Mofokeng (J498/13) Johannesburg J 498/13 2013 06 11 Z T Mtembu & The Safety and Security Sectoral Bargaining Council and 3 others (JR 2870/10) ReviewJohannesburg JR 2870/10 2013 06 11 Cape Clothing Association & C De Kock, N.O. and 2 others (C 1015/12) ReviewCape Town C 1015/12 2013 06 07 South African Revenue Services & Pinky Asanda Ntshintshi and 2 others (C 546/12) Cape Town C 546/12 2013 06 03 The Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd & Artlayk Trading CC and another (4588/12) PMB 4588/12 2013 06 05 Malebo Majatladi & Metropolitan Health Risk Management and 2 others (C 798/12) Cape Town C 798/12 2013 05 31 Cheryl Dorothy Marwick and 2 others & ABSA Bank Limited and 2 others (3351/12) PMB 3351/12 2013 05 30 SAMWU & City of Tshwane and another (J 877/13) Johannesburg J 877/13 2013 05 29 Dr Samantha Naidoo & The Careways Group (Pty) Ltd and another (J945/13) Johannesburg J 945/13 2013 05 28 Z T Mtembu & The Safety and Security Sectoral Bargaining Council and 3 others (JR2870/10) Johannesburg JR 2870/10 2013 05 28 The Trustees of the Lekoa Transport Trust represented by F Vorster in his capacity as Trustee & Transport and Allied Workers Union and another (J 599/13) Johannesburg J 599/13 2013 05 23 Jackson Pule and others & MVELATRANS (Pty) Ltd T/A Bojanala Bus Services (JS 535/2010) Johannesburg JS 535/2010 2013 05 21 Leon Lourens & CCMA and 2 others (C788/2011) Cape Town C 788/2011 2013 05 21 Albion Services CC & Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (D 275/10) Durban D 275/10 2013 05 20 Ingwe Mabala Construction CC and another & Landanani Plant Hire CC (AR550/12) PMB AR 550/12 2013 05 17 Mankakane Violet Magagane & MTN SA (Pty) Ltd and another (JS834/11) Johannesburg JS 834/11 2013 05 16 City of Johannesburg & South Africa Local Government Bargaining Council and 4 others (JR 2996/10) Johannesburg JR 2996/10 2013 05 15 PIKITUP Johannesburg (Soc) Ltd & The South African Municipal Workers Union and another (J 920/2013) Johannesburg J 920/2013 2013 05 14 Rudman Janet & Maquassi Hills Local Municipality and another (J2931/12) Johannesburg J 2931/12 2013 05 14 Distinctive Choice 721 CC t/a Husan Panel Beaters & The Dispute Resolution Centre (Motor Industry Bargaining Council) and 2 others (JR84/2012) Johannesburg JR 84/2012 2013 05 13 SATAWU obo Rune and others v BOSASA Security (Pty) Ltd (C 527/06) Cape Town C 527/06 2013 05 10 National Union of Metal Workers of South Africa (NUMSA) and another & Chin Lung Electron (Pty) Ltd (D915/08) Durban D 915/08 2013 05 10 SCAW South Africa (Pty) Ltd & National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa and another (J 911/2013) Johannesburg J 911/2013 2013 05 08 Lebohang John Mahoko & Mangaung Metropolitan Municipality and 2 others (J 878/13) Johannesburg J 878/13 2013 05 07 Lebohang John Mahoko & Mangaung Metropolitan Municipality and 2 others (J 878/13) Johannesburg J 878/13 2013 05 07 Coca-Cola (Proprietary) Limited v Jabulani Ngwane N.O. and 2 others (D813/11) Durban D 813/11 2013 04 30 Transnet Limited & Transnet Bargaining Council and 3 others (JR187/2010) Braamfontein JR 187/2010 2013 04 29 Greta Joanne Smart & Bytes Managed Solutions, a Division of Bytes Technology Group of South Africa (Pty) Ltd (JS 986/10) Johannesburg JS 986/10 2013 04 23 Woolworths (Pty) Ltd v Commission for Conciliation Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (D787/10) Durban D 787/10 2013 04 22 Solidarity obo M P N De Sampaio & City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality and 2 others (JS 950/11) Johannesburg JS 950/11 2013 04 19 Patricia Diss v Sheltered Employment Factories (under auspices of the Department of Labour) and 2 others (J552/13) Johannesburg J 552/13 2013 04 18 Crown Chicken (Pty) Ltd T/A Sovereign Foods v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (P 337/11) Port Elizabeth P 337/11 2013 04 17 National Union of Mineworkers v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR 2729/2007) Johannesburg JR 2729/2007 2013 04 17 Edward Lemley v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 3 others (P 32/12) Port Elizabeth P 32/12 2013 04 15 Rudman, Janet & Maquassi Hills Local Municipality and another (J595/13) Johannesburg J 595/13 2013 04 15 Rudman, Janet & Maquassi Hills Local Municipality and another (J595/13) Johannesburg J 595/13 2013 04 12 Impact Ltd (Mondi Packaging Sa (Pty) Ltd) & National Bargaining Council for the Wood and Paper Sector and 2 others (JR 182/11) Johannesburg JR 182/11 2013 04 11 The Department of the Premier, Western Cape v Sam Plaatjies N.O. and 19 others (C 515/2011) Cape Town C 515/2011 2013 04 10 Moipone Edith Magomola & North West Provincial Government (Office of the Premier) (JS 827/10) Johannesburg JS 827/10 2013 04 09 SAMWU OBO Nemo and 717 others v Mopani District Municipality (J3047/12) Johannesburg J 3047/12 2013 04 03 Captain M Munsamy v The Minister of Safety and Security and another (D253-03) Durban D 253-03 2013 03 28 Mendoe Dukada & The Mec: Department of Provincial Planning and Treasury- Province of Eastern Cape and 2 others (P 27/13) Port Elizabeth P 27/13 2013 03 22 Trudon (Pty) Ltd & The CCMA and 2 others (JR 2621/10) Johannesburg JR 2621/10 2013 03 22 Concor Projects (Pty) Ltd T/A Concor Opencast Mining & The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and others (J2773/12) Johannesburg J 2773/12 2013 03 22 Concor Projects (Pty) Ltd T/A Concor Opencast Mining & The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and others (J2773/12) Johannesburg J 2773/12 2013 03 22 SAMWU obo Hlonipho MM v SALGBC and 2 others (JR 2159/09) Johannesburg JR 2159/09 2013 03 20 Prof A R Coetzee & 48 others & The Member of the Executive Council of the Provincial Government of the Western Cape and 3 others (C751/2008) Cape Town C 751/2008 2013 03 20 NUM obo Johan Smith v CCMA and 2 others (C 489/12) Cape Town C 489/12 2013 03 20 JDG Trading (Pty) Ltd t/a Electric Express v Osler, A N.O (Cited in his capacity as private arbitrator) and another (JR 1387/09) Johannesburg JR 1387/09 2013 03 20 Thokozani Raymond Mkhize v Mark Antrobus S.C. (N.O.) and another (JR1342/12) Johannesburg JR 1342/12 2013 03 20 PSA obo Strauss & 7 others v Minister of Public Works N.O. and 2 others (C381/12) Cape Town C 381/12 2013 03 20 NUM obo Johan SMITH v CCMA and 2 others (C 489/12) Cape Town C 489/12 2013 03 18 Brinant Security Services (Pty) Ltd v United Private Sector Workers Union (UPSWU) and 117 others (J3339/12) Johannesburg J 3339/12 2013 03 18 Western Cape Education Department v General Public Service Sectoral Bargaining Council and 2 others (C 360/2012) Cape Town C 360/2012 2013 03 15 Mathabathe Pauline Koketso v Emfuleni Local Municipality and 2 others (J511/2013) Johannesburg J 511/2013 2013 03 15 BHP Billiton Hotazel Manganese Mines (Pty) Ltd v CCMA and 2 others (C161/12) Cape Town C 161/12 2013 03 15 Mbhele Musawenkosi v South African Bank Note Company (Pty) Ltd (JS844/11) Johannesburg JS 844/11 2013 03 12 Mzwandikle Douglas Jacobs & Witzenberg Municipality and 2 others (C139/2013) Cape Town C 139/2013 2013 03 12 Vermaak, M v Taung Local Municipality (JR315/13) Johannesburg JR 315/13 2013 03 12 Farmers Meat Supply v Vusi Mgwenya (N.O.) and 2 others (JR248/2011) Johannesburg JR 248/2011 2013 03 08 Saville Row (Pty) Ltd t/a Webbers Clothing and Footwear v Commission for Conciliation Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR2742/07) Johannesburg JR 2742/07 2013 03 05 L A Crushers (Pty) Ltd & The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR 941/10) Johannesburg JR 941/10 2013 03 05 UASA and another v BHP Billiton Energy Coal South Africa Ltd and another (J 354/13) Johannesburg J 354/13 2013 03 02 Mustek Ltd v Joseph Tsabadi NO and 2 others (JR 2732/2010) Johannesburg JR 2732/2010 2013 03 02 FEMPOWER a division of the Workforce Group (Pty) Ltd v The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR837/2010) Johannesburg JR 837/2010 2013 03 01 Trans-Caledon Tunnel Authority & Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR 3009/11) Johannesburg JR 3009/11 2013 03 01 Mutual Construction Company (Pty) Ltd & CCMA and others (J305/2013) Johannesburg J 305/2013 2013 03 01 Mutual Construction Company (Pty) Ltd & CCMA and others (J 305/2013) Johannesburg J 305/2013 2013 03 01 C Arends and others v SALGBC and 2 others (P107/12) Port Elizabeth P 107/12 2013 02 27 Land Bank v L. Nowosenetz N.O. and 2 others (JR3392/10) Johannesburg JR 3392/10 2013 02 27 Ntambanana Municipality v Xolani Caesar Mzobe and 2 others (D801/10) Durban D 801/10 2013 02 26 Satinsky 128 (Pty) Ltd t/a Just Group Africa v Dispute Resolution Centre and 2 others (JR 1479 / 2012) Johannesburg JR 1479/2012 2013 02 26 Public Service Association of South Africa and another v PSCBC and 2 others (D751/09) Durban D 751/09 2013 02 26 Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (Pty) Ltd & Tokiso Dispute Settlement (Pty) Ltd and 2 others (J 1830/11) Johannesburg J 1830/11 2013 02 26 Hulme, Yvonne Merle v KLM Consulting Services (Pty) Ltd (JR 1256/05) Johannesburg JR 1256/05 2013 02 26 Angelfish Investments 536 CC & The Body Corporate of Orient Gardens (9362/2012) PMB 9362/2012 2013 02 22 H & A Manufacturing (Pty) Ltd & Jennie Pender-Smith and 2 others (D124/12) Durban D 124/12 2013 02 22 Melinda Botha v CCMA and 2 others (P160/11) Port Elizabeth P 160/11 2013 02 22 Lithotech Africa Mail Cape, A Division of Bidvest Paper Plus (Pty) Ltd and another & Statutory Council for the Printing, Newspaper and Packaging Industries and 2 others (C 887/2011) Cape Town C 887/2011 2013 02 22 LITHOTECH Africa Mail Cape, A Division of Bidvest Paper Plus (Pty) Ltd v Statutory Council for the Printing, Newspaper and Packaging Industries and 2 others (C 887/2011) Cape Town C 887/2011 2013 02 21 Xakaza Temba v Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality and 2 others (JS281/11) Johannesburg JS 281/11 2013 02 18 Chicken Management Services (Pty) Ltd t/a Kentucky Fried Chicken & The Bargaining Council for the Food Retail, Restaurant, Catering and Allied Trades and 2 others (JR 1717-11) Johannesburg JR 1717-11 2013 02 18 Latinsky & Co (Estate Late JE Latinsky) v F Mooi NO and 2 others (JR17/12) Johannesburg JR 17/12 2013 02 15 Jennila Naidoo v The Minister of Safety and Security and another (JS566/2011) Johannesburg JS 566/2011 2013 02 15 Eugiene Ulster v The Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd and another (C647/2012) Cape Town C 647/2012 2013 02 15 Deon Du Randt v ULTRAMAT South Africa (Pty) Ltd and another (C376/2012) Cape Town C 376/2012 2013 02 14 DENOSA obo N E Mangena v MEC for Department of Health, Western Cape (C914/11) Cape Town C 914/11 2013 02 14 Thembasile Justice Makinana & 15 others v Albert Muller Harbron t/a Harbron Quarries and Groenendal Boerdery (P285/07) Port Elizabeth P 285/07 2013 02 13 B. Langton Construction CC & Quipmore Business Finance (Pty) Ltd and another (8201/2011) PMB 8201/2011 2013 02 12 Powertech Transformers (Pty) Ltd (Formerly ABB Powertech Transformers (Pty) Ltd) v The Metal AND Engineering Industrial Bargaining Council and 2 others (JR 1250/09) Johannesburg JR 1250/09 2013 02 12 Mawethu Civils (Pty) Ltd and another v National Union of Mineworkers and others (P 562/11) Port Elizabeth P 562/11 2013 02 11 NEHAWU, PSA, HOSPERSA, PAWUSA & others v MEC: Department of Health, Eastern Cape and 3 others (P118/11; 125/11 & 127/11) Port Elizabeth P118/11; 125/11 & 127/11 2013 02 08 The Member of the Executive Council Free State Provincial Government: Tourism, Economic and Environmental Affairs v Chaka Johannes Moeko and 2 others (JR 2582/07) Johannesburg JR 2582/07 2013 02 08 Irene Matsie Langa v South African Local Government Bargaining Council (Mpumalanga) and 2 others (JR 3420/2009) Johannesburg JR 3420/2009 2013 02 08 Tubatse Chrome (Pty) Ltd v Metal and Engineering Industries Bargaining Council and 3 others (JR 2679/10) Johannesburg JR 2679/10 2013 02 08 Bidvest Bank Limited & Nasima Rafee and 2 others (JR 1412/11) Johannesburg JR 1412/11 2013 02 08 Cullinan Diamond Mine (Pty) Ltd & S S Molapo and 2 others (JR2061/2010) Johannesburg JR 2061/2010 2013 02 07 Hanwill Mafofela Mining CC v National Union of Mineworkers, Kekana S and 39 others (JS 961/08) Johannesburg JS 961/08 2013 02 07 Consol Ltd t/a Consol Glass v Ker NO & Others (C429/01) Cape Town C 429/01 2013 02 07 Dipone Orapeleng Tsietsi v Lekwa Local Municipality and another (J20/13) Johannesburg J 20/13 2013 02 06 The Regional Commissioner Correctional Services, Free State and Northern Cape v Wolfaardt and 5 others (JR 557/08) Johannesburg JR 557/08 2013 01 31 Devanand Malek v Transnet Bargaining Council and 2 others (D32/10) Durban D 32/10 2013 01 31 Majota Kambule v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR 721/10) Johannesburg JR 721/10 2013 01 29 Cook4life CC v Commission for Conciliation Mediation and Arbitration and 2 others (JR 350/2012) Johannesburg JR 350/2012 2013 01 25 Airports Company South Africa v Khumalo, Patrick and 2 others (JR1010/11) Johannesburg JR 1010/11 2013 01 24 Motitswe Benjamin P Bennito & City of Tshwane (J 88/2013) Johannesburg J 88/2013 2013 01 24 Motitswe Benjamin P Bennito & City of Tshwane (J 88/2013) Johannesburg J 88/2013 2013 01 24 Continental Oil Mills (Pty) Ltd v Commissioner M Singh N.O. and 2 others (JR2152/2010) Johannesburg JR 2152/2010 2013 01 24 The Department of Correctional Services v General Public Service Sectoral Bargaining Council and 2 others (P 340/09) Port Elizabeth P 340/09 2013 01 23 Kelly Group Ltd v Busisiwe Moira Khanyile and 2 others (D 28/11) Durban D 28/11 2013 01 23 Siyabulela Mxalisa and others v Dominion Uranium Joint and another (JR1475/10) Johannesburg JR 1475/10 2013 01 23 Borotho Naledi v Royal Serve Cleaning (Pty) Ltd and another (JS1138/11) Johannesburg JS 1138/11 2013 01 23 COWUSA obo individual v CCMA and 3 others (JR 3124/12) Johannesburg JR 3124/12 2013 01 17 Frans Masubelele v Public Health and Social Development Sectoral Bargaining Council and 2 others (JR 1151/2008) Johannesburg JR 1151/2008 2013 01 07 Masiye Rose v The MEC for Education: Mpumalanga (J3340-2012) Johannesburg J 3340-2012 2013 01 07 Mthuthuzeli George Ndwanya v South African Local Government Bargaining Council and 2 others (JR853/2011) Johannesburg JR 853/2011